Chris Dickinson, Divisional Vice President, Revenue Strategy, Aimbridge, HSMAI Revenue Optimization Advisory Board Member
Have we become so efficient at how commercial work gets done that we are at risk of no longer developing future commercial leaders?
That question shaped a recent discussion among members of the HSMAI Revenue Optimization and Marketing Advisory Boards about how AI, automation, centralization, specialization, and changing operating models are reshaping commercial careers. These advances are not the problem. They can eliminate lower-value work and create more time for strategic thinking. The risk is assuming that the experiences that have historically developed commercial leaders will still occur naturally as the way commercial work gets done continues to change.
The experience gap is not simply about having fewer years of experience. It emerges when changes in how work gets done reduce access to experiences that historically developed judgment, business acumen, operational understanding, influence, accountability, and learning agility without organizations intentionally creating new ways to build those capabilities.
The Experiences That Built Commercial Judgment
Advisory Board members recalled assignments early in their careers that forced them to figure things out: missed forecasts, owner meetings that went poorly, difficult conversations, unfamiliar problems without a roadmap, and responsibility for decisions before they felt fully prepared. Some of those experiences involved manual work that technology has appropriately eliminated. Others came through operational exposure, cross-functional problem-solving, imperfect information, and accountability for outcomes with real consequences.
The objective is not to preserve manual work simply because people once learned from it. The more important question is what those experiences actually developed.
Often, the answer was judgment, business acumen, operational understanding, accountability, influence, and learning agility. People learned not only by observing decisions, but by participating in them, eventually owning them, and reflecting on the outcomes.
The objective is also not to recreate earlier career paths. The work itself has changed, and many of those changes are positive. As technology and new operating models remove some experiences, organizations need to understand which capabilities may disappear with them and intentionally create new ways to build those capabilities.
Operational Perspective Matters
On-property experience remains one of the most effective ways to understand hotel operations, guest expectations, frontline realities, and the tradeoffs behind commercial decisions. One Marketing Advisory Board member described asking front desk teams about their biggest challenges as a quick way to understand what was happening at the hotel. But the resume path matters less than the perspective gained from it.
Not every future commercial leader must begin in a hotel role. Every leader does need meaningful exposure to how hotels operate and how commercial decisions affect guests, owners, operators, and frontline teams. Organizations can create that exposure through property assignments, rotations, market visits, cross-functional projects, and direct partnership with hotel leaders.
The goal is not to prescribe one career path. It is to ensure future leaders develop an operational perspective regardless of the path they take.
What Experience Does a Future Leader Need?
There may not be one right career path, but development should become progressively more challenging. One way leaders can think about experiential development is as a progression: exposure creates awareness, participation builds understanding, ownership develops judgment, reflection turns outcomes into learning, and increasingly complex assignments expand enterprise perspective.
The experiences themselves will differ by role and organization. What matters is whether they deliberately build judgment, business acumen, operational understanding, influence, accountability, and learning agility. Commercial leadership development should begin well before someone receives a leadership title, with the ultimate goal of preparing people to take broader commercial and enterprise responsibility.
Ownership also means allowing emerging leaders to make consequential decisions within appropriate guardrails. Not every decision will be right, and that is part of development. The objective is not to tolerate poor execution, but to deliberately debrief outcomes so people understand what worked, what did not, and why. Reflection is what turns experience into development.
From Functional Expertise to Enterprise Leadership
Deep functional expertise remains important, but expertise in one discipline does not automatically prepare someone to lead across Commercial. Future leaders need opportunities to understand how Revenue Strategy, Sales, Marketing, Distribution, Operations, and Finance connect, where priorities compete, and how decisions in one area affect outcomes in another.
Functional expertise may earn someone greater responsibility. Enterprise perspective is what prepares them to lead across the commercial organization.
Cross-functional development should therefore progress beyond observation. Emerging leaders first need exposure to how other disciplines make decisions. They then need opportunities to participate in shared decisions and ultimately own outcomes where priorities compete, information is imperfect, and there may not be one obvious answer.
Judgment becomes most important when there is no obvious answer. A system may identify the revenue-maximizing decision, for example, while a commercial leader must also consider customer relationships, channel strategy, operations, ownership objectives, and long-term positioning. Technology can inform the decision. Leadership requires owning it.
AI Can Widen the Gap or Help Close It
AI did not create the experience gap, but it may accelerate it. As technology assumes more routine analysis and execution, commercial professionals may have fewer opportunities to develop through some of the work that historically built expertise. At the same time, AI can create capacity for higher-value work and more intentional development.
That creates an important question: What should organizations do with the time technology gives back?
If every efficiency gain simply results in greater workload, organizations may miss an important opportunity. Some of that capacity can be reinvested in stretch assignments, cross-functional decisions, mentoring, property exposure, strategic problem-solving, and other experiences that build the capabilities future leaders will need.
The same technology that removes some traditional learning experiences can create the capacity to replace them with better ones.
As AI assumes more analysis and execution, the human contribution also shifts. Future commercial leaders will increasingly need to question outputs, interpret context, evaluate tradeoffs, communicate recommendations, and ultimately own decisions.
Technology can inform the decision. Leadership requires owning it.
Training Is Necessary, but It Is Not Enough
Training can teach concepts. Experience builds judgment. Future commercial leaders need both.
Formal education creates an important foundation, but leadership readiness comes from applying that knowledge in increasingly complex situations. Mentoring and sponsorship can accelerate that development in different ways. Mentors help emerging leaders interpret experiences, challenge their thinking, and learn from others’ perspectives. Sponsors create access to experiences individuals may not be able to create for themselves.
Both matter, but neither substitutes for actually owning decisions and outcomes.
Development therefore requires an ecosystem of education, experience, coaching, feedback, reflection, and progressively greater responsibility. The risk is assuming that completion of training equates to readiness for broader leadership.
Development Requires Shared Accountability
Organizations need to create access to meaningful developmental experiences. People leaders need to identify potential, open doors, provide coaching, and progressively increase responsibility. Emerging leaders also need to take ownership by seeking opportunities, asking for feedback, and stepping into assignments that stretch them beyond their functional expertise.
Organizations can create the opportunity. Leaders can open the door. Emerging talent still has to walk through it.
How Do We Recognize Readiness?
If experience is what develops judgment, how should we measure whether someone is actually becoming ready for broader commercial leadership?
Training completion, certifications, tenure, and promotion may demonstrate progress, but they do not necessarily demonstrate readiness. Leaders might instead consider evidence such as increasingly complex decision ownership, the ability to influence across functions, how someone articulates competing business tradeoffs, what they learn from outcomes, and whether they can apply those lessons successfully in unfamiliar situations.
The goal is not development for development’s sake. Commercial leaders ultimately need these capabilities to make better decisions across revenue, profitability, customer relationships, operations, brand strategy, owner objectives, and long-term business performance.
The question for commercial organizations is not whether we should become more efficient. We should. The question is whether we are being equally intentional about what replaces the experiences efficiency removes.
For leaders, there is a simple place to start: identify one experience that was critical to your own development but may no longer happen naturally today. Then ask how you can intentionally create the capability that experience built for someone coming behind you.
The next generation of commercial leaders will not develop accidentally. Building them needs to be as intentional as the technology, structures, and processes we are designing around them.
Recommended Reading
- HSMAI Foundation Talent Research
- Building expertise in the age of AI: Who trains the next generation?
- Leadership, artificial intelligence are key for growing commercial talent in hotel industry, experts say
- The Commercial Dilemma: Who Owns Growth When Everything Blends?
Questions for Teams
- What developmental experience contributed most to your growth as a commercial leader, and does that experience still exist for emerging leaders today?
- As commercial organizations become more centralized, automated, and cross-functional, what developmental opportunities are most at risk of disappearing?
- Which developmental experience is most difficult to replicate through training programs, and why?
- What experiences should organizations intentionally create for future commercial leaders rather than expecting them to acquire through career progression alone?
- What developmental experience are future commercial leaders least likely to receive naturally, and therefore most likely to require intentional organizational support?